So last year for my Education and the Polity class, I wrote a paper on educational tracking. For those of you who don’t speak Educationalese, tracking is when you group students together based on ability. Even at my last internship at Franklin High School, students were tracked into academies which focused on obvious directions such as college bound students (Honors and Public Service Academies) and trade students (Engineering! Woot for CREATE!). I realize the theoretical as well as practical arguments for and agaisnt tracking in the States. Little did I know that the tracking battle would following down to the tropics!
Yeah, after Infant 2 (Second Grade) and entering into Standard 1 (3rd Grade) the students at Claver School get assigned to classrooms based on attendance records. Though no one says it officially, these classes are hereby referred to as either “least, middle, or most focused” behind closed doors. And don’t think that the kids are dumb enough not to notice these groupings. Speaking in terms of efficacy, attendance records may not be the best of tools to decide tracking but they get the job done all the same. For the most part, the differences are stark and have been growing for the last six years.
The “most focused” class was a pain the first week. They have been placed with the least experienced/authoritative teachers because they are seen as self-starters. So, they are used to a certain level of anarchy and being able to do whatever the hell they wanted. Then they met me and realized I meant business for the most part. Now, they realize that if they don’t listen and take notes they’re not going to pass their quizzes. I made four versions of the same quiz to ensure they wouldn’t cheat and they said “Wow, you’re smart, Sir”. For the most part, they are bound for high school. There are even a couple who should be in high school already will easily pass the PSE.
The “middle” class was fantastic compared to the other two the first week. I guess they were just testing me out and looking for week spots, because now they are my worst behaved and least respectful. They openly mock me (my name, my accent, and the fact that I have no power outside of the threat of sending them to the office). They are truly little shits.
The “least focused” class, gave me a ton of trouble the first week, but can be managed with help from another teacher. For the most part I’ve learned to ignore the ones who don’t listen and focus on the ones who do (at least keeping it quiet enough for those students to hear me!). The kids who don’t listen have short attention spans and can’t even take notes from the board without constant supervision. The sad thing about a lot of these kids is that once they fail the PSE they’ll have no chance to go back to school and will be out on the street and forced to be much more adult than they are ready to be. Some of them will get trade jobs, others will wind up on the corner smoking pot at 14 years old. I try to tell myself that these students have far too many problems for me to handle by myself, but I still can’t help but think of them when I see another robbery or murder on the news perpetrated by another kid with no way out of poverty.
Of course, all of these classes have exceptions, especially when the classes are based on attendance. There are students in the “most focused” class who aren’t going to pass their entrance exam unless they work their asses off for the next two months. There are some students in the “least focused” class who raise their hands for every question and get really mad when I don’t call on them every time. I guess the “least focused” group is helpfully removed so as not to provide a distraction for the other classes, but there are goof-offs and antics in every class. So, as I write my lesson plans I have to plan for how I’m going to attack the same lesson in three different ways for the different classes. One thing that I could work on is making sure that the students who will not pass the PSE get something from my lessons. I know that there will be some students in each class who don’t pass. If at least a couple of students from each class pass, though, I will have considered myself a success.